Five Things We Learned from Round 16

It's St George against the west

It was a weird final round, with four of the five leading sides failing to win.  A draw against Mosman was enough for Parramatta to clinch the minor premiership after St George tumbled to a loss in the local derby against Sutherland, even though Kurtis Patterson weighed in with 93.  Wests went down to Hawkesbury, but had enough of a cushion to remain in the top six, while Hawkesbury grabbed sixth place after Randwick-Petersham were held to a draw by Gordon.  All of which means that the final six consists of St George and five clubs from western Sydney – Parramatta, Fairfield-Liverpool, Western Suburbs Hawkesbury and Penrith.  Fun fact: apart from St George, the most easterly club in the First Grade finals is the one called Western Suburbs.

Tym Crawford has our favourite stat of the season

Gordon captain Tym Crawford ended the season with 607 runs at an average of 30.35, which is nothing like his spectacular season of 2023-24, but… perfectly respectable.  Plenty of First Grade batsmen would happily settle for those numbers.  But that’s not what’s interesting.  For one thing, over the course of the season, Crawford scored his runs at better than a run a ball – even though his overall strike rate dropped to 104 after he lingered for 72 balls while scoring 42 against Randwick-Petersham in the final round.  Even better – he reached six hundred runs in the season without ever once scoring fifty.  His highest score was 49 against Easts, and he also managed two 48s, two 47s, a 46 and a 42.  We can’t find any previous occasion on which a batsman has failed to reach 50 in a Sydney First Grade season, but still made 600 runs.  Add that to his strike rate and it’s possible that no one has ever played so many fast but shortish innings over the course of a season.

Tim Cummins hit a milestone or two

Sydney University’s finals campaign stumbled at the last hurdle, but in what felt like a rebuilding year for the club, it was an achievement to remain in contention as long as they did.  Despite that disappointment, there was plenty for the Students to celebrate at Mark Taylor Oval: Kieran Tate collected his 150th First-Grade wicket, Jack Hill added another fifty to his solid season’s work, Cameron Frendo continued his steady improvement and Max Hope signed off, in his last innings before retirement, by blasting 38 from only 14 balls.  But the game was also memorable for Tim Cummins, who caught David Lowery from Hayden Kerr’s bowling to complete his 300th dismissal behind the stumps for Sydney University.  Only the late Alan Crompton has previously reached that milestone for University.  A short while later, Cummins was in the game again, catching Corey Miller to record his 500th dismissal in First Grade – he executed 199 for Penrith between 2009 and 2017.  As well as which, he also notched his 6500th First Grade run.  For the past decade, Cummins has been one of the two or three most consistent keeper-batsmen in Sydney, and he’s now joined the very small group of players to record 500 dismissals in a Sydney career.

Cam Merchant came back

Five Things’ favourite left-handed reality TV veteran, Cam Merchant, is, his website says, a speaker, presenter, coach and mentor.  Which sounds like a lot, even before you add – number ten batsman.  We’re not sure that Merchant has ever filled that spot before, but he’s come back to help out Manly in the last couple of games of the season and somehow found himself, against Campbelltown-Camden, going in at the fall of the eighth wicket.  It was a strange game: at one end, wickets had fallen quickly, while at the other, Joel Davies was blasting the ball to all parts of the park.  Manly lost its first three wickets for only five runs; then Davies and Ahillen Beadle added 204; then six wickets fell for 43 runs.  When Davies was out for 155, Merchant was left with the dubiously reliable company of Ryan Hadley, but they both played positively and the last wicket added 72 before Merchant fell for 41 (which is also, cutely, his age).  Merchant also held onto a sharp catch at slip as Manly completed a comfortable win on the second day.

Weird game of the round was at Snape

Snape Park used to have a reputation for being one of the less reliable pitches in Sydney.  It has been a lot better in recent years, but rain had an impact on the final-round match between Easts and Bankstown.  Easts were lodged inside the top six, and Bankstown were running last, but Bankstown looked set for an upset when Easts were dismissed for only 84.  Bankstown captain, Jehan Bilimoria, did most of the damage, grabbing four wickets for only three runs.  Bankstown had a relatively straightforward task to complete the upset, but the side had reached 200 only once this season, and its batters were not high on confidence.  Three wickets went down for five runs, all to Vincent Daly; the eighth wicket went down at 38.  Amazingly, though, the innings occupied 73.4 overs.  It shouldn’t be possible for a team to bat for 73.4 overs and not chase 84, but Bankstown pulled it off.  Praneel Kavuri and Talha Khalid doggedly added 35 runs for the ninth wicket, but Steven Lewis removed Kavuri, and ten runs were still needed when Daly accounted for Khalid.  Daly finished with the absurd figures of five for 18 from 27.5 overs, while Lewis had three for 10 from 21.

Five Things e Learned from Round 15

Win and you’re in

So it’s the time of year when we get out the slide-rule and calculator and work out who needs to do what to get in to the finals.  This season, though, at least in First Grade, we could just about work it out on our fingers.  Unusually, in the final round, every team in the top six plays a team below it on the table and outside the top six – so, basically, win and you’re in.  There’s still a contest for the minor premiership: Parramatta, on 69, has the edge, but if they were to slip up against Mosman, St George (64) could pass them by beating Sutherland.  By beating Northern District last weekend, Western Suburbs (55) more or less ensured themselves of a place in the finals, although if they were to lose to Hawkesbury, you could come up with scenarios involving outrights that would have them missing out.  It’s after that, that things get interesting.  Fairfield (59) should beat North Sydney to secure its spot, but if they were to lose, and three of the five teams behind them win, they could yet miss out (which might turn on quotients).  Randwick-Petersham (51) needs to beat Gordon (47), while Gordon needs a big win and a heap of other results to fall its way.  Penrith (48) needs a win over Blacktown to hold on to sixth spot; Sydney University (also 48) needs to beat Northern District and hope that either it somehow gets its quotient above Penrith’s or that one of Randwick or Penrith loses.  Gordon and Hawkesbury (47) have legitimate hopes, but need other results to go their way – or outrights, or ties, or draws, but let’s not go there.

The top six is pretty much set in Seconds

It’s not mathematically impossible that seventh-placed Easts (50 points) could pull off an outright win over fifth-placed Bankstown (61) -but unless that happens, the top six will remain as it is, though the order could change a little.  The winner of Sydney University (72) and Northern District (67) will finish first unless Campbelltown-Camden (65) can beat sixth-placed Manly (58) outright.

Third Grade is complicated

Once you allow that outright points are possible, twelve teams still have a chance of reaching the Third Grade finals.  Parramatta (64) should clinch first place by beating Mosman, who are running 15th.  University of NSW (59) will be in the finals, and it would take a series of freak results for St George (55) to miss out.  But Hawkesbury (53), Northern District (51) and Manly (51) could all drop out if they lose.  The chasing pack includes UTS North Sydney (50), Sydney University (49), Bankstown (49) ad Gordon (48), who can all get in with a first-innings win and lucky results elsewhere, while Wests (44) and Easts (42) both need ten points and lots of luck.

Fourth Grade is close

With two days left before the finals, four teams are still in with a chance of taking first place in Fourth Grade.  Manly, Sydney University and St George are all on 67, with Parramatta six points behind.  Northern District (54) needs a win over Sydney University, or it could be overtaken by Sutherland (50), who would need to upset St George, or Mosman (49), who would need to surprise Parramatta.  University of NSW is currently sixth on 53, and would expect to see off 15th-placed Sydney to clinch a spot in the finals.

Manly is pretty good in Fifth Grade

Manly’s Fifths (76) have scored the most points of any team in the five grades, but are not yet sure of the minor premiership – if they were to slip up against Campbelltown-Camden (seventh, on 52), they could be passed by Parramatta (72), who have what looks like a less demanding game against Mosman (currently 15th).  St George (65) will be there, and Easts (55) are pretty safe, especially since they’re facing bottom-of-the-table Bankstown.  If Penrith (53) or Northern District (52) drop points, they could be passed by Fairfield (47) or even, with outright points, by University of NSW (45) or Sutherland (44).

Five Things We Learned From Round 14

Life moves pretty fast sometimes

It doesn’t seem so very long ago that Sydney University was stuck at the foot of the First Grade ladder, struggling to win a game and unable to bowl out their opponents.  In the first three rounds of the competition, the Students took only 13 wickets while leaking 842 runs.  Darcy Mooney’s bowling figures were so gruesome that, in some States, you needed to be over 18 to view them online.  Now, though, University sits in equal sixth place, out of the top six only on quotient, and its last two wins have come through defending small targets.  Mooney, with 5-28, was mainly responsible for shooting out Randwick-Petersham for just 134, as the Students defended a sub-par total of 192 at Coogee.  Mooney bowls from a fair height, and hits the seam on an awkward length around the off stump.  He made a key breakthrough early on Sunday when Ben Monetdoro closed the bat face and lobbed a leading edge into the gully, and he found a perfect line to draw an outside edge from Anthony Sams.  Kieran Tate squeezed the ball through Riley Ayre’s front-foot prod, and there was no way back from 4 for 17, Mooney cleaning up the tail after lunch.  University’s modest score owed most to Jack Hill, batting time, and some lower order defiance from Cameron Frendo, who also chipped in with two wickets.  University has perhaps the hardest run home of any team in finals contention, but at least it has momentum on its side.

We don’t do predictions.  But…

As there are already enough ways to look foolish, we don’t attempt predictions here at Five Things.  However, as a general rule of thumb we always think that teams need about 60 points to be sure of reaching the First Grade finals.  The way this year’s table looks, the magic number could be as high as 59 or as low as 54.  St George (58) beating Parramatta (59) means that the race for first place is still live, and players from both clubs should cancel any holiday plans they had for late March.  Fairfield is third on 52, but if it lost to Sydney University next round, would need to beat UTS North Sydney to secure a finals place.  Similarly, if Randwick-Petersham loses to St George in Round 15, it will need a big win over Gordon.  Wests (49) can kill off Northern District’s (43) hopes next week, although a win for the Rangers could leave the Magpies needing a big win over Hawkesbury (42) – who can stay in the hunt by beating Campbelltown next week.  Even ninth-placed Penrith (42) has a chance of reaching the finals if other results fall its way.  And, as we always say, this is the time of year when rain and outrights throw everything into chaos.

Riley Kingsell looks interesting

Bowling first at Bankstown Oval, Northern District had the better of the early exchanges: Kake Cincotta had the dangerous Ryan Felsch caught at slip from a loose drive, and left-arm dart-thrower Jonty Webb had Daniel Solway caught behind from a slower delivery.  Four wickets fell for 90 runs – but NSW Under-19 opener Riley Kingsell was still there.  Kingsell played cautiously early on; leaving anything he didn’t need to play, and scoring only ten runs from his first 35 balls.  But then he accelerated, playing some powerful strokes through the off side and bringing up his fifty (from 69 balls) with a sweetly timed drive over long on from Toby Gray.  He pulled Jon Fullagar to the midwicket fence, then drove and hooked two more boundaries in the over.  He brought up his hundred from 138 balls, plonking Gray over midwicket for another 6.  Altogether, his 149 occupied 195 deliveries, and set up Bankstown’s winning total.  Kingsell looks calm, well-organised and powerful: it will be interesting to watch his progress.

Brock Fitton is on a roll

Last season, Mosman’s opening batsman Brock Fitton averaged 11 in First Grade.  This year, he’s getting the hang of it.  His 92 against Penrith back in Round 10 was notable for containing twice as many 6s (four) as 4s, and then he broke through with a maiden First Grade hundred – 164 against St George in Round 13.  And, sure, these were second-innings runs, but they were second innings runs against a strong attack pressing for an outright, so not to be sniffed at.  Anyway, no sooner had Fitton broken through with his first hundred than he added another, as Mosman chased 338 to beat Campbelltown.  Fitton set us the chase with an excellent 121: he has certainly learned how to make the most of the short boundaries at Allan Border Oval, which he cleared six times.  He drives cleanly, and whacks anything short through the on side.  His second successive hundred helped Mosman to squeak home with the last pair at the crease, a rare bright moment for the Whales, who dragged themselves out of last place on the ladder.

Weird game of the week was at Don Dawson

Fairfield-Liverpool’s Third Grade opener, Raghavan Selvaratnam, made a pretty good start to the game against Penrith.  He whacked four boundaries, racing to 20 from 20 balls.  Then he got out, and about an hour later, the game was over.  Fairfield lost eight wickets for 13 runs to Riley Brandl (four for 6) and the vastly experienced Pete Gregersen (four for 8).  It then took Penrith only a ball more than ten overs to knock off the runs, without losing a wicket.  Wides were the second highest scorer in each innings.  And, which could well be a record, even though Fairfield sent down only 10.1 overs, they managed to use seven bowlers to do it.  Plus, for added weirdness, even after that result, Fairfield remains two places above Penrith on the competition ladder.

Five Things We Learned from Round 13

The Students stayed in the picture

The race for finals places has reached an intriguing stage, with only two points separating four teams in the battle for the sixth spot.  Sydney University kept in touch with a tight win that leap-frogged the Students over their opponents, Campbelltown-Camden, on the table.  University is in a rebuilding stage, but this win was secured by its old hands.  Damien Mortimer played a sensational innings of 80, full of crisp drives and clean pulls, going past 7000 First Grade runs in the process.  Tim Cummins was as efficient as ever behind the stumps, and in front of them scored another vital half-century, while Kieran Tate regularly picked up crucial wickets by attacking the stumps.  But perhaps the best and strangest performance of the match came from Campbelltown’s Jake Scott, who began by bowling tidy but unspectacular leg-breaks before lengthening his run and bowling with unsettling pace and bounce.  He ended up with 6-28, and didn’t really deserve to be on the losing side. 

Anthony Sams has a record

It took him 16 years to do it, but last weekend Randwick-Petersham’s Anthony Sams created a piece of history when (by catching Gordon’s Joey Gillard during the Limited Overs semi-final) he collected his 543rd First Grade victim behind the stumps.  That made him the most successful wicket-keeper in the history of the competition, passing the record set by St George’s immaculate Ernie Laidler.  If 16 years sounds like a long time to wait for a record, spare a thought for Laidler, whose career for St George spanned the 30 years from 1928-29 to 1957-58.  Laidler, who had the benefit of keeping wicket to Bill O’Reilly and Ray Lindwall, was considered good enough to play for New South Wales, but was chosen only twice – in a wartime fixture against Australian Services, and in a one-day match against Fiji, seventeen years later.  Perhaps his batting held him back: although he scored a First Grade century, his lengthy career produced only 2859 runs at an average just below 13.  No-one could say that of Sams, who has recently passed 9000 First Grade runs.  His reward for all that has been a single Futures League match, which feels a touch insufficient.

Parramatta and Randwick-Petersham are in a final

It’s Anthony Sams Week here on Five Things, because it’s impossible to ignore his 78 from 80 balls in the Limited Overs semi-final against Gordon.  Four overs into the game, Randwick-Petersham was two for 13 and Gordon probably felt they had a decent chance – but that was snuffed out by a third wicket stand of 151 between Sams and Austin Waugh.  Waugh produced his best innings of the season, accelerating towards the end to reach 139 from 147 balls.  He brought up his century by launching Jack Shelley over wide mid-on for one of his five 6s.  Gordon chased hard, but after Tym Crawford fell to Riley Ayre in the thirteenth over, the innings subsided.  Luke Callanan wrapped things up with a hat-trick.  There was a closer contest at Old Kings, where Parramatta scraped home against St George.  Once again, Parramatta’s seam attack controlled the game: Michael Sullivan found Blake Nikitaras’ outside edge with the fifth ball of the game, drew Ed Pollock into a skied slog-sweep and won an lbw decision against Nick Stapleton.  At that stage St George was 3 for 13.  Matt Rodgers battled hard for 65, and after 36 overs, St George had reached 4 for 120, with the prospect of posting a decent target.  But Ryan Gupta’s direct hit from midwicket ran out Rodgers as he attempted a second run, and Kyle Thornley removed Tom Vane-Tempest and Adam Singleton with his next two deliveries.  Chasing 132, Parramatta looked comfortable at 2 for 72, but Peter Francis and Connor O’Riordan bowled so well that when the ninth wicket fell, 17 runs were still required.  Ryan Gupta swished unsuccessfully at Luke Bartier, then nurdled a ball behind square for two; Isaac Earl missed a cut at Stapleton, then chipped past midwicket for two; and, critically, five leg-side wides brought the target within reach.  Gupta survived a huge appeal for lbw, and then in the 48th over, Earl clipped the winning run through the on side.  It may not be the last time these two sides see each other in a final this season.

NDs had a big win in Green Shield

There was less joy for Parramatta in the Green Shield final, which was one-way traffic from the moment when Northern District won the toss and chose to bat.  Lachlan Bartlett and Zach Haddin dominated from the outset, sharing an opening stand of 150 in 28.1 overs.  The first over of the match was a 12-baller, featuring five wides, a no-ball and Bartlett’s slogged 4 from the free hit.  Altogether, Parramatta sent down 21 wides and 7 no-balls – far too much generosity for a final.  Bartlett and Haddin have been the basis for ND’s success in the tournament, and although Bartlett fell for 84, Haddin was still there at the end of the 50 overs, unbeaten on 112 from 137 balls.  Parramatta chased gamely, but never looked in the hunt, and Bartlett added three wickets to his impressive innings.

Brynmor Mendel hits it a fair way

You are, let’s say, Sydney’s Second Grade team.  You’re playing Manly, you bowl first, and the pitch is a lively green.  Three balls into the innings, Ellis Sherriff has Lachlan Coyte caught behind.  Then Sherriff catches Matt Brewster’s slash at James Caparelli, and traps Jordan Daly in front of his stumps.  It’s 3 for 18.  The new batsman has a name – Brynmor Mendel – that sounds like a minor character in Lord of the Rings.  He’s a chunky left-hander who  hasn’t scored a fifty in his last nine matches. Are you worried?  You are not.  You’re on top.  You’re still on top, actually, when Mendel has faced six balls and has only a single to show for it.  At which point, the game takes an irrational turn.  Mendel picks up a ball from Sherriff that’s outside off stump and not all that short, and pumps it over midwicket for 6.  In Sherriff’s next over, Mendel cuts a 4, misses with a wild swish, and clips a leg-stump half-volley for 6 with little more than a flick of his wrists.  And it doesn’t stop.  Oscar Kirk drops just a fraction short, and disappears over square leg for 6 more; in his next over, he’s cut, slogged and sort-of-driven for 4, 4 and 6.  Mendel now has 54 from 32 balls.  And now you’re worried.  You’re so worried that you don’t really notice that Mendel’s method is to stay deep in the crease and favour the back foot, so maybe bowling a very full length might be an idea?  But he’s hitting them so well it probably wouldn’t make a difference.  In the 79th over of the innings, he swipes Carter Margetson into the leg side for two massive 6s – the 20th and 21st of his innings – only to sky the next ball to Kirk.  He walks off with 231 from 177, and more sixes than anyone has ever hit in a grade innings.  When Manly declares a few overs later, you stagger off the field, trying to understand what just happened and slightly grateful that Mendel didn’t break a few more records.

Five Things We Learned from Round 12

Rain complicates things

Another January, another competition distorted by rain.  There’s no answer to this: it’s built in to a game played outdoors at the mercy of the weather.  But the fact that it’s unavoidable doesn’t make it fair.  Last weekend, Penrith, UTS North Sydney, Campbelltown-Camden and St George each collected wins in First Grade, but there was no time for a result in the other six games.  Sutherland and Eastern Suburbs never even made it onto the field.  By no coincidence, Penrith and St George sit in the top six, with Campbelltown seventh: winning counts double when other teams don’t get on.  With four rounds to go, there are probably still ten clubs with realistic aspirations of playing in the finals – and at least some of those are likely to be disrupted by the weather as well. 

We have semi-finalists in the Limited Overs competitions

The quarter-finals of the First Grade Limited Overs competition were held last Sunday, and turned out to be pretty lop-sided: there were no close games, and in three of the four matches, the side batting first was rolled quickly, suggesting that the persistent rain left plenty of juice in the pitches.  Conor O’Riordan and Peter Francis reduced Hawkesbury to 5 for 17, after which there was only going to be one result: at Pratten Park, Gordon’s Ash Premkumar and Callum Bladen were even more destructive, as Wests crashed to 7 for 29.  At Coogee, Randwick-Petersham stumbled to 3 for 33 before recovering to reach 9 for 203, English import George Bell contributing 39.  But Eastern Suburbs’ response never got out of first gear, and Austin Waugh polished off the innings with a spell of 4-11.  In the semi-finals, Parramatta meets St George while Randwick-Petersham plays Gordon.

The Green Shield finals are happening, too

There was more excitement in the Green Shield quarter finals, also played on Sunday.  In a match reduced to 24 overs a side, Northern District edged out Mosman by 19 runs, mostly because Lachlan Bartlett blasted 108 from 83 balls.  Bartlett has had an interesting series – his scores (65, 85, 0, 57. 0 and 108) suggest that it’s a good idea to get him out before he scores.  Wests eased past University of NSW, largely because of Martis Johri’s 5-28.  Sydney University recovered from an early collapse to squeeze past St George, thanks to Xavier Quoyle’s polished 62 and another fine spell of leg-spin from captain Arnav Yadav (4-34), who set a new record for University in the competition when he took his 22nd wicket.  At Merrylands, Gordon’s Archie Hetherington wrapped up the Parramatta innings with a hat-trick, but Gordon’s pursuit of 195 appeared doomed when the first five wickets fell for only 68.  Sam David and Sam Dillon repaired the innings with a seventh-wicket stand of 57, and when Arhan Shah took the ball for the final over, Gordon’s last pair needed six runs to win.  Shah produced a nerveless performance to hold Gordon to three singles, and Parramatta held on by just two runs. 

Jeremy Nunan is in form

Campbelltown-Camden’s solid showing in First Grade this season owes a great deal to Jeremy Nunan, who has picked up 38 wickets with some consistently hostile new-ball bowling.  University of NSW actually dominated large parts of the match at Raby, dismissing the hosts for only 200 after good work by Declan White (5-42) and Irishman Gavin Hoey (3-46).  Jack Harwicke-Owen scored an impressive fifty in the Bees’ reply.  But the decisive period in the game was the top of the University of NSW innings, when Nunan and Raheem Abdul grabbed five wickets for 43 runs.  Nunan drew Mahsen Narvel into a poorly-judged hook, which was well held by Abdul at fine leg, nicked off Nihal Desai, and forced Suffan Hassan to retire hurt after striking him with a short delivery.  He ended the innings with 4-61.  Another important contribution came from Ryan Clark, who swung hard for 38 late in the order, and picked up two vital wickets. 

Mosman’s lower graders could use some practice against finger spin

Not that we’re a qualified coach, exactly, but it strikes us that this week at training, Mosman’s lower graders might do a bit of work on how to play finger-spinners who turn the ball a bit, but not that much.  In Fifth Grade, Mosman succumbed for only 73 in 36 overs, with the highly experienced left-arm tweaker, Patrick Lindsay, picking up four for seven in 12 overs.  Lindsay sent down 72 balls, and runs were scored from only five of them.  That was a better effort, though, than Mosman’s Third Grade, who lasted only 33.2 overs and scored just 38.  The destroyer was off-spinner Liam Whitaker, who did the hat trick in his first over by dismissing Jamie Dunk, Thomas Elliott and Flynn Farquharson (who, with that name, should never, ever play for anyone but Mosman).  Mosman lost five wickets with the total on 12, and Whitaker ended up with 7 for 8 from 13 overs.  Meanwhile, in Seconds, off-spinner Harry Gardner picked up six Mosman wickets, admittedly at slightly greater expense.  Anyway, there it is – finger spin, guys, it’s an issue for you.  There will be no charge for this advice.

Five Things We Learned From Round 11

Parramatta will be playing in the finals

Here at Five Things, we don’t make predictions, because we already have enough ways in which we can look stupid.  But here’s one: Parramatta can get ready to think about playing finals cricket in March.  There are five rounds to go, all of them two-day games, which means that theoretically each side could gain another 50 points, which means that as a matter of simple arithmetic, even Mosman (last place, one win, 10 points) could reach the play-offs with a string of outrights.  However, as we say every season, generally if your team gets 60 points, you play in the finals, and turning into the New Year break, Parramatta already has 52.  Parramatta doesn’t have an easy draw after Christmas (Fairfield, Penrith and St George will all be hard to beat), but it does play two of the sides that are currently in the bottom three, and on our reckoning it only needs two wins to stay in the top six.  Its demolition of Northern District in Round 11 was brutally clinical: Michael Sullivan and Isaac Earl reduced the top order to 5 for 34, so that an eventual total of 110 represented something of a recovery.  Then, against an attack containing three representative bowlers (Pawson, Anderson, Gray), Parramatta cruised to victory with eight wickets and nearly 17 overs to spare.  They look like a side who will win more than two of their last five games.

But we have eight more finalists already

50-overs cricket is the unloved bastard child of the game, not as demanding as red-ball cricket, not as fun as T20, but kept alive because every four years the 50-over World Cup generates vast amounts of money for the ICC.  Cricket Australia handles the 50-over problem by playing its competition so early and so late in the season that we bet you didn’t even remember that it’s still going on (New South Wales plays its next game in February, at something in Hobart called Ninja Stadium, which sounds both dangerous and a little ridiculous).  NSW Premier Cricket deals with the issue by grafting the One Day Cup onto the Belvidere Cup, so that teams play in two competitions simultaneously.  That can make it hard to keep track of the fact that the One Day Cup is actually happening, until December when – whoosh! – we now have eight quarter-finalists.  Parramatta, unsurprisingly, finished on top and will meet Sydney University at Old Kings in late January.  Randwick-Petersham will plays Easts in a local derby, while Gordon will play Wests.  On Saturday, Hawkesbury produced an exceptional bowling performance to upset St George – defending only 142, Aidan Van den Nieuwboer (4-29) led a highly disciplined bowling effort, reducing St George to 8 for 68 and 100 all out.  Hawkesbury’s reward for that effort is a home quarter-final against… St George.

We need to talk about Tym

Last season, Gordon captain Tym Crawford dominated the competition, forcing his way into the NSW Second Eleven with 1303 runs at 56, and claiming a share of the O’Reilly Medal.  This season, he’s already played fourteen innings, and hasn’t yet reached fifty.  That could suggest that he’s lost form, or is batting badly, but it’s a bit more complicated than that.  He actually seems to be batting pretty well, just not for very long.  Last weekend was a good example: chasing Blacktown’s 147, Gordon lost two for 12 in the first four overs, with Lancashire quick Jack Blatherwick in hostile form.  Crawford promptly slapped Blatherwick for two boundaries, then hit two more fours in Benjamin Butler’s first over, and raced to 36 from 26 balls before miscuing Blatherwick to Smit Raval.  Crawford has played a lot of innings like that this season: 18 off 17 against St George, 48 from 46 against Manly, 24 from 16 against Northern District, 24 from 20 against Campbelltown… and there are plenty more like that.  Most games he’s been dismissed trying to force the pace in a limited-overs contest.  He actually has 339 runs at 26.08, which isn’t brilliant, but has faced only 287 balls.  Gordon needs to win most of its last five games to have a chance of reaching the finals, and will be hoping that the return to two-day cricket gives Crawford the opportunity to build some longer innings.

Sam Robson can beat you on his own

Sam Robson has been around for so long that the way your remember him may vary, depending on what stage of his career he was in when you first saw him.  Maybe you recall the 16 year old leg-spinner, who took six wickets on his First Grade debut for University of NSW, but batted at eleven?  Or perhaps you saw the England opening batsman who hit 127 against Sri Lanka at Headingley in 2014?  More recently, he’s been a solid senior pro for Middlesex, who makes occasional appearances for Easts over the Christmas holidays.  Anyway, Fairfield will remember him as the player who can beat you almost single-handed.  Fairfield did well enough to reach 9 for 261 against Easts last Saturday, with Luke Ohrynowsky leading the way with 109 from 108 balls.  The total may have been larger but for the fact that Robson was the most economical of the Easts bowlers allowing only 41 runs from his ten overs, and removing Brent Williams.  The many admirers of Sam’s father, James (“Jungle”) will be pleased to see that Sam now bowls in the approved family fashion, which is to say by bowling from a short run with no pause at all between deliveries, allowing the batsmen no time to reset between balls and getting through his overs in seconds rather than minutes.  Anyway, Robson followed up his spell with a dominant innings of 160 not out from only 154 balls, featuring a six, 15 fours and a partnership of 138 with his brother Angus (51).  He finished the game in style, lashing three successive balls from leg-spinner Yash Dekmush for 4, 4 and a six over cover.

Green Shield has started

The early pace-setters in this season’s AW Green Shield (Under 16) competition have been Northern District, Sydney University, University of NSW and Parramatta, who have all won each of their first three matches.  Northern District has a well-balanced attack, in which Ed Byrom and Lachlan Bartlett have performed strongly, a very capable all-rounder in captain Finn Bailey, and a handy opening batsman – Zac Haddin – with a strong Northern District pedigree.  Hamilton Seoung has been in great form for Parramatta, notching 110 against Mosman and 73 against UTS North Sydney.  For UNSW, Neel Patel (167) and Nirav Sharma (103) shared a massive opening stand of 279 against Bankstown.  And Archie O’Hara (a Wests Illawarra product) has been in outstanding form for Sydney University, posting 74 against UTS North Sydney, 135 not out against Bankstown and 55 against Hawkesbury.  The competition resumes with Round 4 on 9 January (when the two University teams are drawn against each other).

Five Things We Learned from Whatever That Was That Happened Last Weekend

Jack Attenborough likes Dubbo

We have absolutely no idea what to call that bunch of games that happened last weekend.  Some First Grade teams played two games in Dubbo, others played one game in Sydney, and the lower grades thrashed around for twenty overs a side.  It was… a lot.

Anyway, Jack Attenborough doesn’t care, because he went to Dubbo and hit 96 against Manly, then 100 against UTS North Sydney, coming home with a heap of runs and two wins for Sydney University.  After a slowish start to the season, Attenborough is now well and truly back to his best, striking the ball with impressive fluency.  But his excellent batting may not have been the most interesting accomplishment by a University player on the weekend. University went west with a curiously-balanced attack of two seamers, three slow left-armers, and few other options, which meant that at some stage the Students were likely to resort to the seldom-seen medium pace of captain Damien Mortimer.  It’s fair to say that Mortimer’s bowling hasn’t progressed quite as expected since he took 5 for 3 in Bankstown’s Fifth Grade side about fifteen years ago.  The game against UTS North Sydney was his 188th appearance for Sydney University, and he hadn’t taken a single wicket in the previous 187.  But he took up the attack with the Bears four down, and Harrison Ward (74 from 70) looking like the key man in the chase.  Mortimer’s first over was tidy, his second was a maiden, and then he found the edge of Ward’s bat, for Tim Cummins to complete one of his five dismissals on the day.  Not only that, but Mortimer’s seven-over spell yielded only 18 runs, so devotees of low-trajectory medium pace may have even more to look forward to in the coming weeks.

Josh Clarke is in decent nick

Josh Clarke was another player to flourish on the western plains, facing 177 balls in Wests’ two matches and scoring 200 runs from them.  His 160 not out (from 152 balls) set up a hefty target for UTS North Sydney, and his 40 from 25 helped the Magpies home in a tight contest with Manly.  Ethan Jamieson, James Psarakis and Farhan Zakhail all contributed useful runs over the weekend, but Clarke’s efforts were exceptional, taking him past 600 runs for the season.  He has now passed 9500 runs in First Grade cricket, moving into the top thirty run-scorers in the entire history of the competition.  Only seven players have scored more First Grade runs than Clarke without playing first-class cricket for New South Wales.  Although it seems like he’s been playing for ever, Clarke’s only 32, so on current form he could be very much higher up that list by the time he finishes up.

Evan Pitt is a handy Second Grader

It’s probably fair to say that Parramatta has the most efficient seam attack in First Grade at present, which explains why Evan Pitt is going around in Seconds.  There’s no fuss about what Pitt does: he runs in from a short approach of about nine paces, bowls with a high arm, hits a length around off stump, and does a bit either way.  His fourth ball on Saturday hit the seam, bounced a little, seamed in a little, and Josh Matthews chopped it into his stumps.  Ben Bryant dragged his first ball straight into mid-wicket’s hands.  Finley Hill took seven runs from the second over of the innings, then tried to pull a ball from Pitt that was nowhere near short enough, and was bowled.  Nicholas Taylor chopped on first ball, and then Matt Coles lunged forward to his first delivery, but not quite far enough, and was given out lbw to complete the hat-trick.  Sixteen balls into the innings, Easts were five for 8.  They didn’t win.  Pitt had five for one from his first ten balls, so his eventual figures of five for seven from four overs probably came as a slight disappointment.

Callum Barton knows the way to the boundary

There was an arm-wrestle at Sutherland Oval, where Northern District and Sutherland grappled all day and nobody won (except, of course, for cricket).  Northern District put together an odd innings, in which eight batsmen reached 15, but only tailender Ross Pawson reached thirty.  Tharindu Kaushal, the former Sri Lanka Test off-spinner, suffocated the innings by giving up only 20 runs in his 10 overs, picking up the wickets of Nicholas Hook and Danul Dassanayake in the process.  Chasing 200 for the win, Sutherland started solidly, if a touch slowly, reaching one for 65, before Pawson and Lachlan Fisher worked through the top order, and Toby Gray contributed ten neat overs.  Sutherland’s sixth wicket fell in the 43rd over, with 85 runs still needed from 46 balls.  The last of the specialist batsmen was Callum Barton, promoted from Seconds only a couple of games ago.  Barton responded to the crisis by hoisting Gray for six, then bashing a ball from Fisher over the fence.  64 runs were needed from the last four overs, but Barton peeled 16 from a Charlie Anderson over, including another six, and then cracked 18 runs from the 48th over of the innings, bowled by Jonty Webb.  28 runs were needed from the last 12 balls, and that became 17 from the final over after Ross Pawson delivered a tidy 49th over.  The experienced Scott Rodgie took the ball for the final over, and the inexperienced Barton cracked the first two deliveries over the boundary: five needed from four.  But as soon as the equation tipped in Sutherland’s favour, Northern District struck back.  Rodgie removed Barton and Thomas Pinson with his next two deliveries.  Rhys Cattle not only dodged the hat trick, but levelled the scores by hitting his first delivery for four.  Cattle middled the final ball, but hit it straight to midwicket, and couldn’t beat the throw back to Rodgie, which left the game tied.  In a game where the batsmen were seldom truly in control, Barton’s innings of 74 from 41 was an exceptional contribution.

Peter Francis is having quite the season

We often talk about the strength of St George’s batting, and about the depth of the club, but really Peter Francis is the engine that keeps the whole thing running.  Only a few weeks ago, he beat Eastern Suburbs almost single-handed by scoring 99 and taking 4-41.  St George, depleted by BBL commitments, lost to Gordon on the weekend, thanks mostly to Jack Shelley’s impressive hundred and some good new-ball work by Ash Premkumar.  But Francis yet again supplied the cutting edge to the St George attack, coaxing life and movement out of a pretty placid Chatswood pitch, and collecting five for 40 from his ten overs.  Already he has 30 wickets this season for St George, who need to do everything they can to make sure he’s fit for the business end of the competition.

Five Things We Learned From Round 9

Rain messes things up

Happy travellers of the week are the Eastern Suburbs First Grade side, who made the trek down to Raby to watch Sam Skelly bowl precisely three balls.  But at least they got on.  Play was possible in only one other First Grade match, at Coogee, where the sandy ground drained quickly enough to allow a 15-over match between Randwick-Petersham and Sydney.  Sydney was always struggling after Daniel Sams whipped out Louis Kimber and Nathan Doyle with the second and third balls of the game, and at the end of four overs, the score was six for 19.  A couple of decent partnerships then lifted the total to 96, and Sydney had a glimpse of a chance when Kimber removed Daniel Sams with Randwick-Petersham four for 38.  But Daya Singh and Riley Ayre steadied the chase, and Ayre hit a six to win the game with eight balls to spare.  Good luck to Randwick-Petersham, who seized their chance, and so jump to fourth spot on the table.  All points are good, but points when no one else gets on are even better.

Only two people really know how this works

It’s a limited overs game.  Team A scores 3 for 141 from its 25 overs.  Team B scores 7 for 142 from 25 overs.  So who wins?  Team A, obviously. 

Those were the precise scores from the Second Grade match between Sydney University and Hawkesbury on Saturday. The reason, of course, is that a break for rain occurred while University was batting first, so the number of overs was adjusted during play, and the Duckworth/Lewis/Stern method applied, meaning that Hawkesbury needed to chase rather more than 141 when it batted second.  No-one complains much about DLS because, intuitively, it seems quite fair: if you start out thinking that you have 50 overs to bat, you don’t play the same way you would if you knew you had only half as many, so an adjustment to the target seems to even things out.  And yet, does anyone understand it?  Here’s just one part of the DLS equation:

Clear?  We can think of only two people who have played First Grade who could make any sense of this at all (Greg Mail and Michael Cant, since you ask), and we’re a university club.  Anyway, by scoring fewer runs than their opponents from the same number of overs, the Students won their ninth match straight, and they can now pretty much take the second half of the season off and still make the finals (although this is not recommended).

We nearly had a record at Cook Park

Penrith’s Fourth Grade had immortality within its grasp on Saturday, and bottled it.  Anyone can get bowled out for 63: it takes something special for a team to score less than ten.  That appeared possible, briefly, when Penrith set out to chase 125 from 20 overs.  In the spirit of seasonal good cheer, we won’t name the batsmen (they know who they are), but Northern District’s William Byrom took a wicket in his first over.  Matthew Brown took two in his first over: three for two.  Another to Byrom in the third over of the innings: four for three.  Brown failed to take a wicket in the next, frankly rather disappointing, over, but never mind – a run out made it five for four.  When Byrom struck again in his next over, the innings was 27 balls old and the score was six for six.  Then a string of singles spoiled things until Brown took his third wicket, and some kind of history was still possible with the score on seven for ten.  But Brendan Vella had to spoil things by playing well and hitting 25, denying his team a rare opportunity to achieve a truly historic catastrophe. 

Theertha Satish had a day to remember

The weather improved enough on Sunday to allow most of the Women’s Premier matches to proceed, and there was a memorable contest at Chatswood Oval, where tidy bowling by Gordon’s Grace Poole and Ahilya Chandel (and the mix up between wickets that cost Frankie Nicklin her wicket) reduced Sydney University to three for five in the fourth over.  University had recovered only as far as five for 38 when left-hander Theertha Satish came in.  Satish began with a couple of crisp drives, but soon the eighth wicket fell with the total on 59, and University appeared set for a heavy defeat.  But somehow Satish contrived to squeeze 55 runs from the last two wickets (of which her partners made five), defending sensibly and then peeling off 15 runs from the 17th over with some meaty blows through and over mid-on and a neat clip past cover.  In the last over of the innings, Satish connected with a clean strike over midwicket for six, before reaching her fifty from only 37 balls and then falling to the last ball of the innings.  A total of 114 was more than University had any right to expect after its start, and Zoya Thakur and Nicklin both followed up with an early wicket.  University never really relaxed the pressure, but Gordon fought back to reach three for 87, needing a run a ball from the last 27 balls with seven wickets in hand.  In those 27 balls, though, seven wickets crashed for 21 runs, with loopy spinner Isabelle Afaras (3-21) doing most of the damage as three wickets tumbled in the final over and University stole an unlikely victory by just six runs.

Sydney will be tough to beat

Just at the moment, the best kind of cricketer for a Women’s club to have is a representative player back from the WBBL who isn’t currently in the Australian side.  Sydney has two of them, and they both showed up at Drummoyne Oval last weekend.  Sammy-Jo Johnson picked up 2 for 7 from her four overs, Maitlan Brown collected 1 for 5 from hers, and Campbelltown was slowly suffocated, managing only 52 runs in 20 overs.  For good measure, Johnson then went out and banged 30 not out from 21 balls.  Sydney sits on top of the First Grade ladder, and will take some catching.

Five Things We Learned from Round 8

Hawkesbury are serious contenders

It’s not unfair to Hawkesbury to say that, over its close-to-forty years in the Premier Cricket competition, the Hawks haven’t always pressed for a place in the First Grade finals.  Last season, Hawkesbury finished dead last, with only a single win to its name.  This season, though… seven games in, Hawkesbury has won five of them, and sit in third place on the ladder.  Much of the team’s success has been due to the form of Jack James and Taj Brar with the bat, but on Saturday it was the bowlers who orchestrated the demolition of Sutherland.  Ryan Fletcher did the early damage in seam-friendly conditions, whipping out Andrew Deitz and Adam Whatley and running out Brendon Piggott.  At that point, Sutherland was 3 for 23 after 13 overs, and there was no way back into the contest, with Aidan Van den Nieuwboer and Smit Doshi cleaning up the back end of the innings.  In the end, the game was decided on Duckwoth/Lewis, but Hawkesbury never looked like dropping the points.

Two Irish leg spinners walk into a bar…

The concept of an Irish leg-spinner sounds like the start of a joke (and if you know how it ends, please let us know), but there are actually two of them playing in Sydney this season.  Gordon has Gareth Delany, who has already made an impact with the bat, while Gavin Hoey, at University of NSW, has made a quieter start to the season.  But Hoey made a telling contribution on Saturday.  Going in with the Bees on a wobbly five for 129, he hit his first two balls to the boundary, then launched Joshua Malone for a pair of sixes on his way to 39 from 24 balls.  He was economical with the ball, and prised out Anthony Adlam and Alexander Lee-Young from Mosman’s middle order, as the Bees got home in the rain by 21 runs.  Hoey played two one-day internationals for Ireland against South Africa earlier in this year (in Abu Dhabi, obviously); his father, Conor, also bowled leg-spin for Ireland, back in the day when Ireland played almost all of its games against Scotland.

Seamus Meaker had a good day

Seamus Meaker’s name makes him sound like he should be an Irish leg-spinner, too, but in fact he bats in the middle order for Sydney.  He came into the Tigers’ top side for the T20 matches earlier this season, and played his first Belvidere Cup game in Round 7, but showed what he could do against UTS North Sydney on Saturday.  Sydney did well to bowl out the Bears for 161, but then, unfortunately, fell in a heap as the vastly experienced James Campbell showed them how to use a pitch that encouraged swing and seam.  After his first six overs, Campbell had 3 for 19, and Sydney had stumbled to 4 for 42.  The fact that they remained in the hunt at all was due to Meaker, who was unbeaten on 51 at the end of the innings, reaching his half century by hoisting two successive sixes from Mac Jenkins. 

Will Adlam hits a long ball

To readers of a certain age, the concept of W Adlam hitting the ball out of the ground will be comfortingly familiar.  Warwick Adlam played seven one-day games for New South Wales, mostly as a distinctly sharp opening bowler, but he was also, on the right day, a left-handed batsman who hit the ball very hard indeed for Gordon, North Sydney and Mosman.  One of his sons, Will, is part of the NSW Under 19s set-up this season, and has played a few handy innings for Mosman’s seconds, without quite showing his best form.  Until Sunday.  Mosman’s Poidevin-Gray side made a slowish start to its T20 match with Fairfield.  Only four runs came from the first two overs of the innings;  when Adlam came in, Mosman was for 3 for 65 from 10.3 overs, leaving only 57 deliveries in the innings.  Adlam faced 37 of them, smashing 12 of them over the fence and four other boundaries, on his way to 104 not out.  He really kicked off in the fifteenth over, when he cracked leg-spinner Yash Deshmukh for two sixes, a full toss banged over midwicket and a meaty slog-sweep.  In the seventeenth over, he took on Fairfield’s spearhead, Javeer Singh Dhanoa, lofting a drive over extra-cover for four, slog-sweeping a full ball on off stump for six, blasting a slower ball past cover for four, and lobbing an on drive just over the boundary for six more.  Ridiculously, 51 runs came from the last two overs, which included four sixes in succession from Aaryan Dixit.  Adlam actually hit sixes from five successive legitimate deliveries, punctuated by a wide bowled by Jai Long.  Perhaps the cleanest hit of his innings was the massive blow over long-on that brought up his century with only one delivery remaining in the innings.  Jai Long had a mixed weekend: on Saturday, he picked up 2-24 from ten overs in First Grade, but the next day his final over in Poidevin-Gray went for 20.

University’s Seconds are still perfect.  Just.

Eight rounds into the competition, only one team in any grade has won every one of its matches – Sydney University’s Seconds.  But it has been closer than you might think.  That unblemished record includes wins over Sutherland by 11 runs, by 10 runs over Penrith and by 5 runs over Mosman.  On Saturday, a strong Parramatta side restricted University’s run machine, Ryan McElduff, to no more than 40 (but not before he passed 700 runs for the season), and held the Students to a very chaseable 8 for 208.  Pete Brazel grabbed two early wickets, but Santosh Samuel and the highly promising Blake Noorbergen then put Parramatta firmly in control with a third-wicket stand of 109.  With eleven overs remaining, Parramatta had reached 3 for 144, needing less than a run a ball with seven wickets in hand, and Noorbergen well set on 74.  The Parramatta innings was played in more or less constant drizzle, and the wet ball didn’t help the bowlers.  But Noorbergen then drove seamer Will Lintott straight to Harrison May at mid-off, and University tightened the screws.  In some ways, the crucial moments were the undramatic ones: May, Henry Snyman and Lintott bowled so efficiently that Parramatta hit only one boundary in the final ten overs.  And then the wickets fell in a crash, with three going down in May’s final over, and University was home by nine runs.  Teams that reach the finals are often the ones that win the close games, and win from unlikely positions.  University Seconds are doing both those things at the moment.

Five Things We Learned from Round 7

Jack Attenborough went large

After transferring from University of NSW last season, Jack Attenborough had a tough first year with Sydney University, partly redeemed by an impressive late-season century.  His innings at Mosman last Sunday suggests that he’s recovered the form that brought him almost a thousand runs for the Bees in 2022-23.  The Students were chasing 310, which seems about par on Allan Border Oval, where the pitch is true and the boundaries short.  Most of Mosman’s top order made starts, but only Nathan Hinton (108) produced the big innings required to post a competitive total.  In reply, Attenborough and Jack Hill (who’s enjoying a striking, late-career run of form in Firsts) set up the chase with an opening stand of 133.  They made an interesting contrast: the stockier Hill favours the back foot and on side, while the feature of Attenborough’s innings was the elegance of his driving.  Together they nullified the threat of Shield bowler Jack Nisbett, and by the time Attenborough fell to persevering left-armer Jake Turner, the result was a formality.  Attenborough batted for just over four and a half hours for a career-best 143.  In this form, he’s a batsman well worth watching.

400 is the new 250

There was a time, not very long ago, when any First Grade side that scored about 250 thought that it had a pretty good chance of winning.  These days, not so much.  In round 7, Mosman scored 310, North Sydney 342 and Northern District 294, and they were all chased down.  But the biggest chase was at Manly Oval, where Gordon posted an imposing nine declared for 449, powered by Irish international Gareth Delany, who hit 152.  449 seems like a winning total, or at any rate not a losing one.  Manly ran it down with five wickets and several overs to spare.  Ash Premkumar knocked over Joel Foster early, but Ahillen Beadle (who’s in phenomenal form) and Jay Lenton (whose run-a-ball 58 gave the innings momentum) shared a second-wicket stand of 133, after which Joel Davies (123 not out) and Beadle (158) added another 148.  Imagine: successive partnerships of 133 and 148, but when Beadle was out, Manly still needed 163 to win.  Bertie Foreman smashed five sixes in his 68, Davies had the maturity to bat right through, and Manly romped to the points. 

Parramatta looks ominously efficient

Sydney’s decision to send Parramatta in to bat looked like a good idea in the handful of overs it took the Tigers to knock over the first two wickets.  The problem with doing that is that it just brings together Ryan Hackney and Nick Bertus, two of Sydney’s most productive batsmen of recent times.  The two left-handers added 71 before Hackney fell, after which Bertus (well supported by Patrick Xie) moved smoothly to his sixteenth First Grade hundred.  Parramatta’s pace attack doesn’t look all that fearsome on paper, but they’re highly efficient, giving nothing away, maintaining pressure and exploiting any movement that on offer.  So far this season, they’ve taken 63 wickets – only St George (68) have managed more.  It took Michael Sullivan, Isaac Earl and Kye Thornley no time at all to reduce Sydney to 7 for 45, after which there was only going to be one outcome.  Parramatta’s win keeps them level on 31 points at the top of the table, behind St George only on points.

Paul Ryan can still beat his age

Five Things doesn’t know one end of a golf club from the other, but we’re vaguely aware that once golfers reach a certain vintage, “beating your age” becomes something worth striving for.  We’ve been waiting to put that little morsel of knowledge to use ever since Paul Ryan made his comeback to Premier Cricket a few years back.  Ryan played in the New South Wales Under-19s back in 1986-87, which makes him, by our reckoning, about 57.  He’s hit a couple of half-centuries over the last few years, without ever quite scoring more runs than his age – until Saturday.  Wests’ Thirds lost early wickets to Bailey Penna and Luca Croft, and never really recovered, but Ryan showed the benefit of all his experience, crafting 64 gritty runs out of a total of 126.  Between 1985 and 2004, Ryan scored 8202 First Grade runs for Wests, Mosman and St George – it would be interesting to know how many he’s now scored in all grades.

Thomas Draca is still available

Enthusiastic followers of the Metropolitan Cup competition probably recall that game a few seasons back, when Sydney University’s Thomas Draca ripped through Warringah to take 7-32 in 6.5 overs.  Draca’s moved on a bit since then.  He played a handful of First Grade games for Blacktown, turned up for a while at Exeter University, and has now become a key member of Italy’s T20 team.  Italy isn’t at all a bad side: it’s full of Moscas, has the odd Manenti, plus Joe Burns and the former Middlesex all-rounder Gareth Berg.  Please believe that they hammer Luxembourg and the Isle of Man.  Draca does his bit, bowling at brisk medium from a good height, hitting an awkward length and varying his pace.  He did well enough to win a place in the Brampton Wolves in Canada’s Global T20, where he played under David Warner’s captaincy and dismissed Sunil Narine on a regular basis.  So why stop in Canada?  Draca has now become, so far as we can tell, both the first Italian and the first ex-Metro Cup player to put himself up for auction in the IPL.  Somehow he was overlooked in the first round of bidding, but he remains available for any franchise with a few crore to spare.  Whatever the Italian is for chutzpah, he has it, and we applaud it.

Five Things We Learned from Round 6

Jaiveer Singh Dhanoa bowls straight

To be honest, we still haven’t quite figured out Jaiveer Singh Dhanoa.  The Fairfield-Liverpool opening bowler ambles in from a short run (which starts with a hint of a Jasprit Bumrah stutter), doesn’t seem disconcertingly quick or bouncy, and doesn’t move the ball around dramatically.  He just keeps getting good batsmen out.  After Brent Williams’ dominant 152 not out allowed Fairfield to close at 9 for 303 against Bankstown, Dhanoa struck two vital blows at the end of day one, bowling Justin Felsch in his second over, and pinning Daniel Solway lbw two balls later.  On the second day, he removed Ryan Felsch and was too good for the tail, as Bankstown collapsed for only 118.  Dhanoa finished with 6-42, five of them bowled or lbw.  As far as we can tell, he’s a touch quicker than you expect from his approach, hits the seam a lot, and bowls very, very straight.  Dhanoa is still in the Under-19 pathway, and his development over the next few years will be interesting to watch.

Dan Christian is still handy

Dan Christian is 41 years old, and it’s been a while since he played in a match that lasted longer than 40 overs.  But he’s still a pretty useful player to have in your First Grade side.  Turning out for University of NSW against Sutherland, Christian went to the crease with his side in trouble at 3 for 46.  He took guard, poked at the pitch for a bit, and then, calmly as you like, drilled his first ball from Zac Philipson through cover for four.  It was a remarkable stroke, with no great backlift and no extravagant swing – just a short, perfectly-timed punch.  In the next over, Thomas Pinson strayed onto Christian’s pads and was whipped to the fence at midwicket.  And Christian carried on in the same vein for the next three hours, picking off every loose ball and hitting it for four – there were 24 of them in all, in his innings of 130 from 156 balls.  Oh, and he bowled, too, running in hard and picking up three wickets.  In his 13th over, he snared Luke Ritchie and Rhys Cattle with successive balls, leaving Pinson to avoid the hat trick by prodding forward hopefully.  The Bees won by a lot.  One thing that has helped to sustain the club over a difficult few years has been the fierce loyalty of a core group of former players, and Christian’s enthusiasm is a perfect example of that spirit.

Sydney can’t be underestimated

It’s doubtful that many people gave Sydney much of a chance of beating Eastern Suburbs but the Tigers showed, not for the first time this season, that they’re not to be underestimated.  Given first use of an unusually spicy pitch at Cricket Central, Sydney’s bowlers made the best of it, budling out the Dolphins for only 119.  Cian Egerton, whose run-up starts from somewhere near deep extra cover, bowled a dangerous line and jagged one back to remove James Matthews lbw.  Two balls later, Angus Robson nicked to third slip, where Will Fort held a sharp, low left-handed grab, and when Trystan Kennedy edged behind, Egerton had taken 3 for 3 in seven balls.  But Sam Skelly was just as effective when Sydney batted, and at the end of the first day, Sydney still needed seven to win, with only two wickets standing.  When play resumed, Tyler Robertson was run out after pushing a single, which left the last pair to make six runs.  Kain Anderson hit Skelly for four, reducing the target to two, but Skelly and Tom Aspinwall then bowled three excruciatingly tense maidens until Kain Anderson sliced skelly away for the winning runs.  Easts had the better of what was left in the game, but it was too late to deprive the Tigers of six valuable points.

Jack James is seeing it well

Also, probably, in the upset category was Hawkesbury’s romp to victory over Randwick-Petersham.  Randwick-Petersham raced to 340 on the first day, scoring at almost four and a half an over and playing with almost cavalier confidence.  But Jack James and Taj Brar ran up an opening partnership of 222, James following his century against UTS North Sydney with an innings of 138.  His last four innings have included two centuries and a 66; it’s fair to say that he’s in decent form.  Brar batted for four and a half hours for his 120, and veteran Dale McKay finished things off with an unbeaten 66.  The result pushes the Hawks into the top six on quotient.

Ryan McElduff is out of place in Seconds

For about twenty minutes, it looked as though the Blacktown Mounties might be able to stop Sydney University’s unbeaten run in Seconds: batting first in tricky conditions, the Students slumped to 2 for 15.  Which brought in Ryan McElduff, who’s playing Second Grade this season through his own choice.  Just over four hours later, University declared at 4 for 349, with McElduff still there on 206.  He played shots all round the ground, especially strong through the on side, and cracked 19 fours and two sixes.  It was the first double-century of his career, the ninth double-century for the club in Seconds and the fifth-highest score ever recorded for the Students in Seconds.  McElduff already has 599 runs for the season, including his 206 not out, a 186, three fifties and an incongruous first-ball duck.  The message for Second Grade attacks this season is to get him first ball, or be prepared for a long afternoon.

Five Things We Learned from Round 5

Jack Hill is less like red wine than you think

Unanticipated MVP of the week was Sydney University’s Jack Hill, whose maiden First Grade century steered the Students to the points against Penrith.  There’s nothing inherently surprising about Hill scoring a First Grade hundred: he began the season in good form, and has over 3000 runs to his name in Seconds, including a double hundred.  It’s just that he made his debut for Sydney University in 2006, and was playing in his 251st Premier Cricket match, and had never before scored more than 19 in First Grade.  We’re reluctant to claim records we can’t quite prove, but we haven’t been able to identify anyone else who has played so much Premier Cricket before reaching three figures in Firsts.

If we were just five percent lazier than we actually are, this is the point where we’d roll out the line about how Hill improves with age like a fine red wine.  But we won’t do that, partly because it’s an awful cliché, and partly because that really isn’t how red wine works.  Certainly, most reds don’t keep getting better once they’ve been in your cellar for 18 years, which is how long Hill has been cellaring in Seconds and Thirds.

Hill batted for three, very different, sessions.  The first was an uncomfortable passage of play on the first evening after University had dismissed Penrith for 124.  The pitch was green and quick, the light indifferent.  Liam Doddrell was hostile and menacing, Sam Grant probing and insistent.  Hill could have been dismissed half a dozen times, but he clung to his wicket tenaciously and guided his side through to stumps with only one wicket lost.  On the second morning, he batted carefully and responsibly with Tim Cummins to take University to within a single run of victory.  Then, after lunch, he stood and delivered, driving, pulling and hacking boundaries all around the ground.  He reached his hundred by carving Doddrell through cover for four.  It was a memorable innings: reports that Hill celebrated with a glass of red wine remain unconfirmed and dubious.

It was a good round to bowl first

Green pitches, heavy skies: it was a good round to bowl first.  The side bowling first won in eight of the ten First Grade matches.  The game between Parramatta and Bankstown was effectively decided within the first 22 overs, in which Bankstown was bundled out for only 80.  Isaac Earl pinned Dan Solway lbw with his second ball, after which Bankstown’s batsmen kept nicking the ball to Dhruv Kant, who held no fewer than six catches (including one spectacular diving grab to remove Riley Kingsell).  Parramatta lost only one wicket before claiming the points.  Similarly, Wests seized the chance to bowl first against Sydney, who managed only 124.  Muhammad Irfan (6-42) did most of the damage, but Finn Gray had the game of his life, taking 4-19 before scoring his first First Grade hundred as Wests piled up a hefty lead.

Riley Ayre is in form

He has always been an all-rounder, but at the start of his career, Riley Ayre probably a bowler who batted.  More recently, he has been more of a batsman who bowls.  This season, though, he bats at four and takes wickets for fun.  On Saturday, against his old club Sutherland, he took a career-best 8-29, the best First Grade bowling figures ever recorded for Randwick-Petersham.  His first wicket was, perhaps, a little lucky: Matthew Hopkins clipped the ball firmly, only for Max Robinson to hang on to a reflex catch at short leg.  Andrew Deitz then slashed at a quicker, wider ball and Anthony Sams juggled the ball before hanging on to it.  Adam Whatley played an extraordinary innings, sweeping his first ball for six, missing a second sweep, and slicing his third ball to slip.  Lachlan Ball was beaten in flight, and prodded the ball to short mid-wicket.  Ayre, left arm orthodox, didn’t turn the ball alarmingly, but he was relentlessly accurate, used the conditions expertly and varied his attack thoughtfully. 

Spencer White looks alright

Every club enjoys it when one of its local products nails down a First Grade place, and Spencer White is the latest batsman to come up through the ranks at Northern District.  White, a graduate of Marist College Eastwood and ND’s Green Shield team, spent most of last season piling up runs in Second Grade, but has well and truly grabbed his opportunity in Firsts this year.  White notched his first century against Campbelltown in Round 4, and followed it up with a savage display at David Phillips last weekend.  There wasn’t all that much pressure when he went in at 3 for 291, but even so, his 57 not out occupied only 26 balls and was an impressive piece of hitting.  He launched five 6s, and with Lachlan Shaw added 104 runs in only 8.5 overs of mayhem.  He’s not, perhaps, the most elegant of batsmen, but he picks up the length very quickly and has a wide range of scoring strokes when giving just a little room to free his arms.  It will be interesting to watch his progress over the course of the season.

The British are coming

The annual influx of English county professionals is now well and truly underway.  It’s not impossible to imagine a universe in which Dom Bess would now be resting up from England’s tour to Pakistan and getting himself ready for a trip to New Zealand.  As it is, the off-spinner played the last of his 14 Tests in 2021 and seems to have fallen off England’s radar altogether.  His first outing for Mosman this season was a mixed bag: he scored a rapid 49 opening the innings, but made no impact with the ball as Fairfield chased down its target with ease.  Leicestershire all-rounder, Ben Mike, picked up an early wicket for Northern District at David Phillips, and his county team-mate Louis Kimber turned out for Sydney against Wests.   Kimber made headlines last season with an absurd innings against Sussex: he went in at 6-144 with Leicestershire chasing 464 to win, and hammered 243 from 127 balls, including 21 sixes (and 43 from a single over bowled by England seamer Ollie Robinson).  No such fireworks this week, but Kimber did follow his four-ball duck by taking two wickets with his off-breaks. The most successful of the imports this week was Lancashire medium-pacer Tom Aspinwall, who collected 4-43 in Eastern Suburbs’ close loss to Manly.

Five Things We Learned from Round 4

We have a winner

Last time we were here, we suggested that maybe St George’s batting strength might be the decisive factor in the final of the Kingsgrove Sports T20 competition.  That prediction looked as clueless as all our other forecasts when, the day before the finals, St George was absolutely rissoled for 93 by Fairfield’s Yuva Nishchay and Jaiveer Singh Dhanoa.  So who did St George play on Sunday in the grand final?  Fairfield-Liverpool again.  Fairfield set St George a target of 166, powered by Coby Holland’s boisterous 65 from 37.  That, on North Sydney Oval, wasn’t obviously a winning score, but after Blake Nikitaras and Kurtis Patterson took 31 from the first five overs, Patterson sliced Hamish Reynold’s first delivery straight to Jaydyn Simmons at point.  Two balls later, Blake McDonald swished at a wide delivery and nicked it to Holland behind the stumps.  Reynolds might even have had a third wicket in the over if there had been a slip in place to intercept Nikitaras’ outside edge.  But in the following over, Brent Williams held a blooped return catch from Matt Rodgers, and St George was deep in trouble at 3 for 36.  At that point, Nikitaras had scored 16 from 17 balls.  From his next 42 balls, he smashed 91 runs.  And he did it, mostly, with pretty conventional batting, rather than reverse dinks and inside-out scoops.  Mostly, he stood still and whacked the ball through the off side whenever he was given any width.  He clipped Reynolds off his toes for four, and when Luke Hodges came on, he picked up a shorter, quicker ball from the left-armer and swung it behind square leg for six.  In the fourteenth over, he chopped Liam Hatcher past slip for four, sliced a drive to the fence at backward point and then hit a third boundary with a sweetly-timed square drive.  He raised his century by driving Hodges high over mid-off, and hit the winning boundary in the following over, with 15 balls to spare.  As if that wasn't enough, he backed up the next Saturday to hit 152 from 117 balls in the second innings of the grade game against Fairfield, who by now must have been sick of the sight of him.  Not a bad week’s work.

Matt Moran came back

Matt Moran hasn’t played for Mosman for a couple of seasons – we assume he’s been trying to perfect the pepper sauce at Aria, or something, although it’s possible we got a bit confused there.  Anyway, on his return to First Grade, he walked out to bat in the local derby against Manly, with the score on 6 for 87 and Ryan Hadley bowling with his tail up.  Understandably enough, Moran started cautiously, but he found things a touch easier when Andrew Boulton replaced Hadley, striking a perfectly timed drive past cover, and playing with wristy elegance whenever the ball went near his pads.  Then he took the attack to the Sussex off-spinner, Bertie Foreman, with a fierce pull shot and a drive through mid-off.  When Hadley came back after tea, Moran was well set, and hooked a short ball in front of square for a flat six.  He added 118 runs with Shehan Sinnetamby, and reached his own century (from 138 balls) by dabbing Thomas Kaye to the third man boundary.  It probably should have been a match-winning innings, but wasn’t, because Mosman batted on into the second day until they had scored 361 and only 80 overs remained.  That turned out to be not quite enough time to bowl Manly out.  Jay Lenton, driving crisply, peeled off his 16th century for Manly – a new club record – but there were 47 balls left when Manly’s ninth wicket fell.  Mosman crowded the bat, but Kaye and Josh Seward played out the draw.

Justin Avendano has resumed usual service

It has been odd this year to watch Justin Avendano turning out for the Blacktown Mounties, not that there’s anything wrong with that, but we’re just so used to seeing him with North Sydney.  Possibly he’s been disoriented, too, because his start to the season hasn’t been as productive as we’ve come to expect.  Well, normal service has been resumed.  University of NSW set the Mounties a testing target of 285 and made some early inroads through Thomas Gibson and Gavin Hoey.  But Avendano and Puru Gaur then took control with an unbroken third-wicket stand of 215, in which they both completed their own centuries, to provide the Mounties with their first win of the season.

Randwick-Petersham look solid

Randwick-Petersham produced the round’s most dominant performance, a clinical effort to crush a pretty decent Western Suburbs side.  A massive total of 5 for 375 was based upon the second-wicket stand of 179 between Austin Waugh (121) and Eknoor Singh (135 not out), each of whom hit his first hundred for the club.  Then skipper Riley Ayre baffled Wests with his left-armers, grabbing 5 for 16 in 16 overs.  As always, Randwick-Petersham seems to have a team composed almost entirely of all-rounders, providing depth in the batting and plenty of options with the ball.

There’s a reason this ground was named after a batsman

There are still a few Sydney University players who have sleepless nights over that game at Mark Taylor Oval some years back, when University seconds declared with a score of 500, an hour before stumps on day one, and lost.  Well, there’s a reason the ground was named after a batsman.  Mark Taylor Oval is back in action this season, and very welcome it is, too – unless your idea of fun on a Saturday afternoon is bowling.  Northern District’s Thirds ran up the small matter of 4-403 against Campbelltown-Camden, with William McFadden – who had a couple of games in Seconds last season – racking up 201 not out from 205 balls.  No sixes!  But he did hit 26 fours, and added 225 for the fourth wicket with Elijah Stead, who hit a hundred of his own.  So that’s a winning score, right?  Well, only if you can take ten wickets.  Northern District took six.  Both Campbelltown-Camden openers (Agnik Podder and Karanbir Kahlon) hit centuries, and the game ended in a draw, in which ten wickets fell for 739 runs.  University of NSW Seconds play at MTO this week.  Spare a thought for their bowlers.

Five Things We Learned from Round 3

It’s finals time!  Already!

To those of us above a certain age (say, 21), October seems a touch early for a cricket final, but here we are: the last day of the Harry Solomon Little Bash is this coming Sunday, at North Sydney Oval, where Bankstown meets St George and Northern District faces Fairfield.  The winners will advance to the grand final, later in the day.  Bankstown advanced largely through the efforts of marquee player Will Bosisto, who had a big day last Sunday, cracking 86 from 50 against Sutherland and 88 from 48 against UTS North Sydney.  Lachlan Shaw’s 107 from 57 was the main difference between Northern District and Eastern Suburbs.  Perhaps the best of the quarter-finals was at Old Kings, where Fairfield-Liverpool needed nine from the last over of the day, and got there when Coby Holland hit Michael Sullivan’s fifth ball to the fence.  As for this Sunday… Five Things doesn’t do predictions, but St George’s batting looks pretty formidable.

Saturday was a grim day for bowlers

It was no fun at all bowling at Sutherland on Saturday – cold and unpleasantly windy – and apart from about ten minutes the game was dominated by the bat.  During those ten minutes, Andrew Ritchie took the first two Sydney University wickets, and Sutherland looked, briefly, like defending its total of 237.  But Jack Attenborough set off with a string of boundaries – his first four scoring strokes went to the fence – and Tim Cummins matched him in a third wicket stand of 150.  Cummins, busy and positive, accelerated through the middle overs and remained unbeaten on 92, while Damien Mortimer, in rich form this season, finished off the chase with 49 not out from 50 balls.  University’s bowlers were little more penetrative than Sutherland’s, but they kept things tight, holding Sutherland to a reasonable total despite Andrew Deitz’s disciplined 116 not out.

You always remember the first one

By which we mean, of course, your first First Grade wicket.  Certainly, Bankstown leg-spinner Mitchell Constantinou will remember his.  And so will his victim, Gordon’s Mitchell Lole.  Constantinou, an Illawarra product, came into the attack to bowl the 32nd over.  Gordon was 5 for 143 and Lole, on 14, looked to be the key man if Gordon was to post a decent total.  Constantinou’s first ball stuck in his fingers.  It happens.  The ball possibly landed in Lole’s half of the pitch, but only just.  He could have hit it anywhere.  But, with unerring precision, he picked out Daniel Solway at short mid-wicket.  You can see it here, https://www.instagram.com/gordondcc/reel/DBDpYEvJ2Yh/, unless Lole has managed to get it taken down in the meantime.  Constantinou went on to bowl six tidy overs for only 20 runs, which everyone is much less likely to remember.

Harry Manenti had a good day

Limited-overs games in October are usually played on flat, slow pitches and dominated by batsmen, so it’s worth acknowledging Harry’s Manenti’s effort for Easts against University of NSW on Saturday.  The fourth bowler used by the Dolphins, Manenti bowled straight at a decent pace, trapping Ryan Meppem lbw, bowling Thomas Byrnes and removing Irish newcomer Gavin Hoey in his first spell.  When he came back at the end of the innings, he was ever deadlier, ripping through the tail in a spell of 4-7 – and that included the five wides he sent down in an over-enthusiastic effort to complete a hat-trick.  The Bees succumbed for only 147, a target that posed no real challenge to Easts openers Daniel Hughes and Will Simpson, who needed only 21 overs to knock off the runs.

The game at Hurstville might be the one when you rest that tight hamstring

We’re not suggesting that the NSW selectors have made a mistake, but there are plenty of grade bowlers hoping that they reconsider the question of whether Blake Nikitaras and Kurtis Patterson are Sheffield Shield batsmen.  On Saturday, they dominated a very respectable Northern District attack, both hitting hundreds while sharing a second wicket partnership of 222 in just over 36 overs.  Patterson was marginally faster, hitting 114 from 112 balls, but the feature of the partnership wasn’t massive hitting, but the ruthlessly methodical way in which the two left-handers rotated the strike and kept the score moving with sharp running and deft placement.  The big hitting came on Sunday morning, when Nikitaras (86 from 46) and Patterson (63 from 38) needed only 14 overs to chase down Penrith’s 146 in the T20 elimination final.  Unless the selectors change their mind some time soon, bowling at Hurstville Oval will not be an enjoyable experience this season.

Five Things We Learned from Round 2

Ahilen Beadle is still going

According to the record books, Ahilen Beadle is only 38, which we suppose we have to believe, although it feels as though he’s been around for a bit longer than that.  That’s more or less how Blacktown’s bowlers felt about him last Saturday, since he faced the first ball of Manly’s innings (bowled by Hunar Verma), and also faced the last (again bowled by Verma), on his way to an unbeaten 190 from 138 balls.  We don’t usually think of Beadle as a big hitter, but on Saturday he helped himself to 120 runs in boundaries, clearing the ropes 12 times and adding 12 fours.  He began to accelerate as early as the fourth over, when he hit Guy Hammond for three fours in succession; then he turned his attention to off-spinner Atharv Deshpande, whose ten overs leaked no fewer than 95 runs.  Beadle swung freely across the line, planting the ball over midwicket so often that the tennis players in the adjacent courts should probably have been issued with helmets.  Joel Foster was a little slower to start, but it scarcely mattered; when Foster was out for 63 in the 30th over, the openers had already added 175.  By the end of it all, Beadle had scored exactly half of his side’s 5 for 380.  Blacktown’s bowlers didn’t help themselves, donating four extra overs to Manly through a coach-killing 23 no-balls.  Beadle first played First Grade back in 2003; this was his 14th first grade century, and easily his highest.

Easts had a day out

Penrith was in the game at Waverley Oval for about five overs, which was how long it took Liam Doddrell to remove Easts opener Nicholas Taylor.  After that, Will Simpson and Angus Robson methodically batted the Panthers out of the game.  The second-wicket pair – the left-handed Singapore international and the former county pro – added 179 in a match-defining partnership.  There were no great pyrotechnics, though Robson did hit five sixes: it more a display of controlled, purposeful batting.  Simpson is tall, left handed and graceful through the off-side; the more nuggetty Robson is professionally ruthless through the on side.  Together they put the match beyond Penrith’s reach, and a mercilessly efficient performance by the Easts attack bundled out Penrith for just 97.

Records were threatened at Pratten Park

Sydney University was without Kieran Tate on Saturday, and Will Salzmann was unable to bowl, leaving the Students with a very inexperienced attack.  Wests openers Josh Clarke and Nick Cutler cashed in, almost batting through the whole of the innings.  Nick Cutler had scored 110, and the total was 262, when he missed a sweep at Bailey Lindgard on the first ball of the 47th over.  Actually, the University bowlers contained Wests reasonably well for lengthy periods, but with wickets in hand, Clarke was able to accelerate with some fearless hitting at the back end of the innings, lashing nine 6s on his way to an unbeaten 175 for 140 balls.  His innings was the highest ever recorded for Wests in a limited-overs game -although the opening partnership was a long way short of a club record.  That would be the unbroken 309 assembled by State batsmen Austin Diamond and Jim Mackay against Middle Harbour in 1905-06 – in, since you ask, just 90 minutes.  Salzmann, Damien Mortimer and Tim Cummins all hit half-centuries in University’s reply, but Wests ran out comfortable winners.

Finn Nixon-Tomko had the best day ever

According to the well-known theory advanced by The Grade Cricketer, the ideal result for a batsman is to score a century in a losing team – because, presumably, then you get all the credit for everything, and none of the blame.  So what do you call it when you score a double century in a losing team in a 50 over game?  If this has ever happened before, we can’t find it, but on Saturday, Gordon’s Second Grade built an apparently unbeaten total of 5 for 385, after centuries by Apurv Sharma and Jamie Bekis.  In the Bears’ reply, three of the top five batsmen were dismissed for 1, but Finn Nixon-Tomko, who went in at three, batted through 48 overs to remain unbeaten on 207.  The left-hander, whose previous best effort in Seconds was a 61, relished the proximity of the Bon Andrews boundaries, cracking 18 fours and 10 sixes.  Gordon still won, but only by 43 runs and after a couple of seasons of decent but unremarkable performances, Nixon-Tomko – son of the former Sydney University and Gordon batsman Craig Tomko – suddenly looks like a very different player.

Peter Ferguson was a link to another time

There are probably few current grade players who have much memory of Peter Ferguson, the former Western Suburbs and Sutherland spinner, who died last week at the age of 74.  But he was certainly a memorable cricketer.  He first played for Western Suburbs in the club’s Saturday afternoon Under-16 team, when he was just eleven.  At the age of fourteen, he took 43 wickets in that competition, 18 in Green Shield, two in Poidevin-Gray, and 60 in Fourth Grade – 123 wickets in that 1964-65 season.  Wests held him back a bit – a young left-arm wrist-spinner was a valuable commodity, and they didn’t want to expose him to First Grade too early.  Still, he made his debut at 17, and took 263 wickets at 21.06.  He played with a smile on his face, turned the ball a very long way, and scored runs rapidly in the lower middle order.  He never quite managed a First Grade hundred, but twice he was left not out in the nineties.  Lesser cricketers appeared for NSW during his career, but he played at the same time as David Hourn – arguably the best bowler of his type that the State has ever produced – and there was room for only one of them in the representative sides.   

A look back at Ferguson’s career reminds us how different grade cricket was back then.  Ferguson was part of the Wests team that won the Rothmans Cup knockout in 1967-68.  But he didn’t bowl much, because usually the opposition was bowled out by Wests’ two Test bowlers (Bob Simpson and Grahame Corling) and two NSW bowlers (Brian Rhodes and Wally Wellham).  In 1975-76, Ferguson was a key member of the Wests side that reached the First Grade finals – which included six current or future Test players (Simpson, Peter Toohey, Steve Rixon, Gary Gilmour, Greg Dyer and Dirk Wellham) as well as NSW representative Wally Wellham.  Never again.

Five Things We Learned from whatever round that was

If your club missed the T20 finals, you’re a touch unlucky

So your club made it through to the finals of the T20 Little Bash?  Well, that’s great – but so did eleven other clubs, which seems just a little bit excessive.  The four pool winners – Campbelltown-Camden, UTS North Sydney, Parramatta and Northern District – go through to the quarter-finals, where they’ll play the winners of the four elimination finals played on 13 October.  In those games, Sydney University plays Easts, Fairfield meets Wests, Penrith will play St George, and Bankstown faces Sutherland.  It’s a touch surprising that teams as strong as Randwick-Petersham and Manly missed out, but early-season T20 is not a predictable game.

Josh Philippe is seeing it OK

Fresh from scoring a century in his first game for NSW, Josh Philippe added another hundred in his first game for Western Suburbs – the first time, we think, that this particular double has been achieved.  Have you seen Philippe bat?  If you pitch the ball up, he whacks it, and if you bowl short, he whacks it.  You could try bowling a length, but then he whacks it.  Chasing 149 against University of NSW, he shouldn’t really have had time to score a century, but he hit 110 not out from only 49 balls.  In the first over, Aryan Patel kept him fairly quiet – he hit only two fours, and ten runs in all.  But the third over, also bowled by Patel, went for 26, with Philippe launching the first ball, and each of the last three, over the boundary.  He ended the game by blasting Tyler Grainger-Baldwin for the tenth six of his innings, giving Wests the points with a ridiculous 43 balls to spare.  Incidentally, this is as good a place as any to express our deep disappointment that Blaize Irving-Holliday stopped playing for University of NSW before he had the chance to turn out alongside Tyler Grainger-Baldwin and Jack Hardwicke-Owen (but then, we are very easily amused).

Tim Cummins has been around

Sydney University’s second T20 match last Saturday was Tim Cummins’ 300th First Grade match, a rare milestone and one which serves as a handy reminder that he’s been one of Sydney’s best keeper-batsmen for some time now.  Last weekend, his keeping was as sharp as ever (he both caught and stumped Blacktown’s Kunj Changela from the same delivery) and his calm leadership steered the inexperienced Students into the elimination finals.  University seems to be short a reliable sixth bowler, which limits Cummins’ options in the field, but Kieran Tate showed his best white-ball form with a four-wicket burst against Blacktown, Dylan Hunter bats like a left-handed Josh Philippe, Damien Mortimer is in good touch, and newcomer Bailey Lidgard has shown a very handy ability to kick the score along in the closing overs. 

One super over is unlucky, but two is ridiculous

We suspect that very few club sides bother practising specifically for a super over, because, be honest, how often is that going to happen?  Well, only twice in two days, if you’re Randwick-Petersham.  It worked out well enough on Saturday, when RPs and Gordon each managed 129 from their 20 overs.  Angus McTaggart held Tym Crawford and Axel Cahlin to just eight runs, before Jack Wood launched Quincy Titterton for six to win the game with a ball to spare.  On the Sunday, ridiculously, Randwick-Petersham tied again, despite drawing level with Northern District’s 164 with six wickets to spare and two balls remaining.  At which point, Riley Ayre was run out attempting a match-winning single, and Alex Ross cracked Toby Gray’s final delivery straight to Lachlan Fisher.  Gray kept the ball for the Super Over, conceding only seven runs, and Nikhil Chaudhary needed only two balls to settle the issues, hitting Ayre for two sixes.  Northern District sailed through to the finals as pool winners, while Randwick-Petersham missed out.  It can be a game of very fine margins.

The round’s silliest game was at North Sydney

The lower grade competition kicked off on Saturday, and the most irrational game of the round was in Second Grade at Bon Andrews Oval, where Bankstown collapsed to 9 for 114 against the home side.  At which point, Koby Layton (who hit four 6s in his 66 not out) and Gurinderjeet Hara (57 not out) put together a rapid, unbroken last wicket stand of 136, more than doubling the score and allowing Bankstown to post a more-or-less par total of 9 for 250.  That looked distinctly useful when North Sydney lost its first five wickets for only 126 runs, with Hara (5-40) completing a memorable double.  But North Sydney’s lower order fought hard, and the game was settled by the other last-wicket pair: Jack Atkinson hit the match-winning boundary with only two balls left in the game. 

Five Things We Learned from Opening Day

Don’t worry, we’re as confused as you are

It’s going to take a while to sort this out.

When the season kicked off last Saturday, with the first two rounds of the Harry Solomon Little Bash, most teams were packed with new players, alongside countless old players in new colours.  It was all very confusing.  Sydney University fielded no fewer than four debutants (Bailey Lingard, Cameron Frendo, Mikey McNamara and Darcy Mooney).  Justin Avendano turned up to play at North Sydney, which is usual, but was playing for Blacktown, which isn’t.  Easts’ top six included three newcomers in Trystan Kennedy (formerly of Gordon), Harry Manenti (ex Sydney) and Jake Cross (from Ipswich).  Connor O’Riordan played in the Randwick-Petersham/St George game, but for St George, not Randwick-Petersham, which felt like Opposite Day.  The point being, sides have changed a lot since last season.  Bear with us.  We’ll probably catch up some time around Christmas.

Dylan Hunter still goes off

There should probably be, somewhere in the playing conditions, a rule that prevents Dylan Hunter from playing at Bon Andrews Oval.  That ground, which some of us still think of as North Sydney No2, isn’t quite big enough to contain him, besides which an expressway runs past it, creating some fairly obvious risks.  Western Suburbs’ total of 7 for 177 felt slightly under par, but it was at least defendable – until Hunter clicked into gear.  The bare statistics of the left-hander’s innings are impressive enough – 123 not out from only 64 balls, with 8 fours and a ridiculous 11 sixes – but what that doesn’t tell you is that Hunter didn’t score at all from the first eight balls he faced.  He got over it, though, hitting Hanno Jacobs for 4 and 6 to get moving, and then carving 18 runs from Jack Bermingham’s first over.  Hunter continued to clear the fence with unusual frequency, and when he slammed the last ball of the 18th over to the boundary, University had strolled to a comfortable victory.  Hunter’s move to Canterbury last season allowed him the opportunity to make his first-class debut and play three List A games, although curiously the New Zealand province didn’t use him in any of its T20 (sorry – make that “Dream 11 Super Smash”) games.  As he showed on Saturday, while he’s a good player in any format, he can be especially destructive in the shortest of them.

Some bloke called Warner showed up

And all credit to him.  It’s rare for any representative player, even a recently-retired one, to show up in Premier Cricket these days, and a batsman like David Warner has little to gain and a lot to lose.  If he’d scored big runs for Randwick-Petersham against Bankstown, that would only have been what was expected, and if he missed out, he left himself open to criticism.  But he turned up and played, and made a memorable game (to the extent that anyone remembers any T20 game) a bit more special for both his teammates and his opponents.  For the record, he started out with two dabbed singles, missed an attempted pull shot and then skied a leading edge from an inside-out drive at Ryan Felsch to deep cover, where Jake Smith held the catch.  Randwick-Petersham really should have won: they needed nine from the last over, with seven wickets in hand and Jason Sangha (who had 72 from 46) on strike.  But Felsch produced a remarkable final over, allowing only two singles from his first three balls.  Alex Ross clubbed the fourth ball to long-on and scampered through for two – four needed from two balls.  Angus Campbell’s smart return ran out Ross as he attempted an impossible second run, which meant that Eknoor Singh needed to hit the last delivery for 4 to win the game.  But Felsch cramped him for room, and he could only chop it away for two, leaving Bankstown victorious by a single run.

The Ghosts are away to a good start

Campbelltown-Camden didn’t enjoy the best of seasons last year, but started 2024-25 in impressive style, winning both of their opening matches.  The Ghosts have recruited well: former Penrith all-rounder Jake Scott kickstarted their innings against Fairfield-Liverpool, hammering 62 from only 35 balls, and cracked 42 from 35 against Manly.  Scott also picked up handy wickets, and another newcomer, Jermey Nunan, showed his wicket-taking potential as well. 

Dave Dubey plays in Sydney now

Dave Dubey has been quietly making a name for himself in Canberra for a couple of seasons now, playing for ANU in the ACT competition and turning out for the ACT side in the Toyota Cup Second Eleven matches.  His start in Sydney was impressive: he opened for Penrith against Sydney and hammered 93 from only 46 balls.  Dubey, who’s only 19, is a tall, wristy batsman who looks capable of adding more power to his game when his spare frame fills out a little. Even so, he hit the ball cleanly enough, especially when repeatedly hoisting Tom Mullen’s spinners over the short midwicket boundary at Merrylands Oval.  He was within two hits of a debut hundred when he got underneath a scoop at Hugh Sherriff and skied it to fine leg, but it was a very promising start nonetheless.

Five Things We Learned from Round 16

Wests’ big week went wrong

It was poised to be a phenomenal week for Western Suburbs – first hosting the grand final of the First Grade Limited Overs competition, then needing only a first innings win over Campbelltown to cruise into the qualifying finals in First Grade. 

It didn’t quite turn out how it was supposed to.  Wests sent Northern District in to bat in the Limited Overs grand final, and bowled well enough early on to justify it.  Jack Bermingham took wickets with successive balls, knocking over Scott Rodgie first ball, while Hanno Jacobs and Muhammad Irfan kept things tidy.  But Lachlan Shaw was dropped twice in the 40s – neither a tough chance – and he took the game away from the Magpies, breaking up Tom Brooks’ line with meaty reverse sweeps and pounding the ball through the leg side.  His 117 from 114 balls was a decisive contribution, and NDs bowlers backed it up to secure what was, in the end, a deceptively comfortable victory.  Wests may well still have been wondering “what if?” when they returned to Pratten Park on Saturday to defend their modest total of 188.  Campbelltown resumed at 28 without loss, but Hanno Jacobs grabbed three wickets in no time at all, Jack Bermingham struck twice, and Campbelltown was soon deep in trouble at 5 for 41.  Brendan Smith (60) and Blake Smith (36) led a recovery but with the score on 139, Brendan’s limp pull at Jack Bermingham lobbed a catch to midwicket and brought Wests back into the game.  In the next over, Blake charged at Tom Brooks, missed and was stumped.  It was 8-143 when Ryan Clark was bowled offering no stroke to a ball from Jacobs that may have seamed back a touch.  Wests then looked back in control, but Thomas Patterson and Luke Meek steered Campbelltown to the points and allowed Randwick-Petersham to jump into the top six.  Wests will still have Seconds and Fourths in the finals, but will feel that things could have been very much better.

Next season, the average height of First Grade players will increase by 3.2cm

Sadly, Round 16 marked the final appearances of two of Sydney’s leading slow bowlers.  At Bensons Lane, Steve O’Keefe worked through 12 wicketless overs as St George made light work of a target of 289.  It was a strangely low-key ending for a career which was played out, largely, before bright lights and big crowds in the BBL.  But it was fitting that it ended more or less where it began – O’Keefe was a Hawkesbury Green Shield player, who worked his way into the Australian Under-19s as a batting all rounder.  His batting probably didn’t quite develop as it might have, but his bowling exceeded expectations. His 6-35 in each innings at Gahunje in February 2017 earned Australia a rare Test win in India, and his 224 first-class wickets for NSW cost only 25 runs each.  More recently, his ability to baffle batsmen with the slowest, nudest deliveries imaginable has enlivened the BBL.  O’Keefe is almost forty, so his retirement doesn’t come as a surprise.  Devlin Malone, though, is not yet 26, so his decision to leave the game to focus on his physiotherapy practice is unexpected.  Like O’Keefe, Malone was a teenaged prodigy, breaking into First Grade at Sutherland at 16 and striking three times in his first over.  He went on to take all ten Sydney University wickets in a Second Grade innings, before joining the Students – so there’s a nice symmetry that he went out last weekend with a win for his second club over his first. In all, he managed 364 First Grade wickets, earned through a combination of accuracy, bounce and variation.  He liked to attack the stumps, and was quick through the air, and perhaps the fact that he didn’t fit the conventional mould of a leg spinner told against him when representative teams were chosen.  A handful of State Second Eleven appearances doesn’t seem like fair recognition for a player who has been the leading spinner in Premier Cricket for several seasons – certainly, many less able slow bowlers have appeared in the BBL over that period.  Anyway, good luck to both – Premier Cricket will be a duller competition without them.

Jason Sangha is back in form

Once Wests stumbled against Campbelltown, Randwick-Petersham needed only first innings points over a depleted University of NSW side – missing the recently-retired Hayden and Brandon McLean – to claim a place in the finals.  That mission turned out to be fairly straightforward.  Predictably enough, the consistently excellent Angus McTaggart did the damage when the Bees batted, grabbing 5-25.  McTaggart, the season’s big improver, now has more than 50 First Grade wickets in this campaign.  But perhaps more importantly, Jason Sangha, who has been out of sorts since Christmas, showed some ominously good form with the bat.  Sangha cracked an unbeaten 130 from only 89 balls, smashing 11 fours and a ridiculous eight sixes.  Four times in his innings, he hit two sixes in an over, and three times he hit two successive balls over the rope.  With McTaggart supplying a cutting edge and Sangha now looking dangerous again, Randwick-Petersham can’t be underestimated in the finals.

Parramatta finds ways to win

Of the six sides in the First grade finals, you can argue that Parramatta is the least exciting on paper – sure, they have Ryan Hackney and Nick Bertus, but otherwise they’re a bunch of workmanlike, unglamorous players.  But they’re the reigning premiers for a reason – someone usually finds a way to get their side over the line.  In Round 16, Fairfield cruised to 4 for 189 and looked set for a large total, before Isaac Earl and Michael Sullivan got to work and the last six wickets added only 61 runs.  Then Parramatta found itself in a hole, after Jaydyn Simmons dismissed Hackney and three wickets were down for only 51 runs.  At which point, contrasting innings from Bertus and Patrick Xie steered Parramatta to a comfortable victory.  Bertus hung in for 145 balls for his unbeaten 67; Xie needed only 90 balls for his 102, cracking left-armer Cameron Frendo out of the attack and rushing to his hundred with a flurry of boundaries from Simmons.  Parramatta has a tough assignment against Northern District this weekend, but you wouldn’t bet against them.

It'll do a bit early…

Convinced that the odds of the game are skewed heavily in favour of the batsmen, Five Things loves a collapse, so we couldn’t go past the Fifth Grade match at Don Dawson Oval, where the last-wicket partnership for Parramatta (30, unbroken) was higher than any partnership that Fairfield-Liverpool managed in its two innings of 33 and 44, and was more runs than Fairfield managed from the bat (28) in the first innings.  The second Fairfield innings looked like a scorecard from the under-tens – nine bowlers were used, the best of whom, Aryan Kumar, took four for five from his six overs.  Kudos to Hrehnan Shah who, with 5 and 19, scored a third of his team’s runs.  For everyone else… well, there’s always next season.

Five Things We Learned from Round 15

Four First Grade finalists are settled

Just two Saturdays to go before finals, and the First Grade table remains more or less as it has been since Christmas – the top four is set, and the rest is a mess.  St George, despite its thumping at the hands of Penrith, will still finish as minor premiers even if they all get lost on the way to Benson’s Lane on Saturday (not that we advise this as a strategy, however tempting it may be).  Northern District, Manly and Parramatta will fill the next three, not necessarily in that order.  And then comes the cluster.  Gordon leap-frogged over Wests to sit in fifth with a strong win over Bankstown, featuring the inevitable Tym Crawford century.  They can make their place secure by beating Blacktown.  But Blacktown is in the mix too – if they beat Gordon, and Wests lose to Campbelltown, they’re in the mix.  Randwick-Petersham can make the six by beating University of NSW if other results fall their way.  You can even construct a scenario in which 12th-placed Fairfield beats Parramatta outright, and a whole heap of other sides lose or draw so that they sneak in to sixth.  And that’s before you factor in ties and rain!  But this is Five Things, not 38 implausible conjectures.

There’s another logjam in Seconds

Only three finalists are known for certain in Second Grade.  Bankstown (73) will be minor premiers if they beat Easts (51), unless Manly (71) beat Penrith (52) outright.  Northern District (65) are all but certain to hold their spot in the top three.  Wests sit fourth on 56, but there are no fewer than five teams who could overtake them with just a first-innings win, so they need to make sure they put away Campbelltown.  Sutherland (55) needs to beat Sydney University to remain in the six, and St George (54) needs a win against Hawkesbury.  If any of them stumble, then Parramatta (53) can sneak in with a win against Fairfield.  But St George will be confident after an impressive win over a strong Penrith side, led by Vansh Jani’s 148 from 100 balls, which included 112 runs in boundaries.

Sydney University will play in the finals in Thirds.  Nothing else is certain

A career-best 6-15 by Darcy Manners gave Sydney University a big win over Parramatta last week, and sealed the minor premiership for the Students.  They sit on 81 points, 14 ahead of Manly.  But even on 67 points, Manly is not absolutely certain to play in the finals.  Behind them sit Easts (65), Northern District (63), Parramatta (62), UTS North Sydney (62), St George (61) and Wests (57) – all of whom could potentially overtake Manly (whose quotient, 1.161, leaves it especially vulnerable).  Manly does have the advantage of playing Penrith, who sit dead last with only two wins.  And there’s one critical match-up: UTS North Sydney play Northern District in what looks like a straight shoot-out for a finals place.  If North Sydney loses, it will drop behind Wests if Wests can beat Campbelltown – who are running second-last with only three wins.

You ignore quotients all year, until you don’t…

Coaches like to shout that every run counts.  Well, sometimes every single run does count.  In Fourth Grade this week, fifth-placed Easts (59) plays Bankstown (53), and if Bankstown wins, it could slip past on quotient, where Easts hold a lead (1.402 to 1.387) so slight that it may not be strong enough to survive a loss by anything more than a run or two.  We don’t really do maths here (there’s a reason we don’t go past Five Things), but we calculate that difference in quotient to equal the over-aggressive throw to the bowler’s end that went for four overthrows back in Round Four.  Still, Easts have a couple of highly experienced players in Oliver Maxwell and Jackson Coutts, and pounded University of NSW last week – James Britnell, who opened the season with successive ducks in Fifths, hit a ridiculous ten 6s in his innings of 93.  There may be some jostling over final placings, but Manly (82), Northern District (75) and Wests (74) will all play in the Fourth Grade finals.  Then there are potentially eight teams jostling for the last three places.  Sydney University (60) has clung onto its place in the six for some time, and has a relatively comfortable draw against fourteenth-placed Sutherland (although more than one finals contender has slipped on that kind of banana skin).  St George sits in sixth, and really should see off last-placed Hawkesbury – but if that goes wrong, Gordon (54) and Parramatta (51) still have a hope.

Manly looks hard to beat in Fifths

Manly are your Fifth Grade minor premiers, having already earned a highly impressive 89 points.  Also safely into the finals are Parramatta (78) and Easts (71), while it would take a series of freak events to displace Gordon (67).  Eighth-placed Wests (53) need an outright win over Campbelltown and another series of freak results, which could include seventh-placed St George losing to last-placed Hawkesbury.  Wests are horribly unlucky – they didn’t get onto the field at all last week, when they would have expected to beat 19th-placed Blacktown.  Essentially, Sydney University (61) and UTS North Sydney (60) face an identical challenge – win and you’re in.  North Sydney’s batting has been unconvincing lately, but a decent attack, steered around by the experienced Patrick Lindsay, usually keeps them in the context. 

Five Things We Learned from Round 14

Mosman’s weekend didn’t work out as planned

With two rounds to go, the composition if the top six is… still nowhere near clear.  Mosman had a chance to cement its place in the six when it played Bankstown, and chose to bat first at Bankstown Oval.  But it took Ryan Felsch only two balls to remove Matthew Calder, after which the Whales fell in a heap.  Nick Browne stood firm for 52 overs, remaining 40 not out, but his team-mates gathered six ducks between them as Mosman was bundled out for only 75.  There was no way back from there, and Bankstown completed the outright win with eight wickets in hand.  Mosman’s next match, against Manly, suddenly looks very important indeed.

Wests had a big weekend

Wests, on the other hand, romped to a big win over Eastern Suburbs, jumping over Mosman to take fifth spot.  And the Magpies also advanced to the final of the Limited Overs Cup.  Yes, it’s still going.  Usually, the First Grade Limited Overs Cup is either compellingly interesting, if your club is still in it, or a bit irrelevant, if you’ve been knocked out.  But there was plenty of interest in Wests’ semi-final last Sunday, because they showed that St George can be beaten.  Muhammad Irfan played a key role, removing Matt Rodgers, Ed Pollock and Blake Macdonald in his first spell to reduce St George to 3 for 26.  Kurtis Patterson (87) and Nick Stapleton (85) then rebuilt the innings with a fourth-wicket stand of 172, which seemed to put their side back on top.  But Irfan (5-32) and Hanno Jacobs (3-41) bowled exceptionally well at the back end of the innings, and the St George total of 239 was a little short of par.  James Psarakis held the chase together with an unbeaten 77, but there was an agonising break for rain when Wests needed 27 from seven overs, with three wickets in hand.  When play resumed,  it took a flurry of late blows from Irfan, whose 32 not out occupied only 31 deliveries, to get Wests over the line.  Irfan, who has long levers and an idiosyncratic technique, hit successive boundaries to complete a memorable match for him and a perfect weekend for his club.  With two rounds remaining, Wests has one grand final appearance (against Northern District) booked, and all five grades are still able to reach the finals.

Smit Raval spoiled the fun for Randwick-Petersham

Needing to win to keep up with the top six, Randwick-Petersham couldn’t have asked for a better start: the increasingly impressive Angus McTaggart (6-31) triggered a collapse that left Blacktown in all sorts of trouble at 8 for 107.  At that point, however, Smit Raval somehow managed to squeeze another 89 runs from the last two wickets, assisted by some incredibly patient blocking by Josh Boyden, who lingered around for 132 balls while scoring 27.  Boyden, a brisk left-armer, was far more entertaining with the ball – he induced Blake Weymouth to prod a catch to Raval at leg slip, and had Jake Egan caught behind with a ball that angled across him.  Jermey Nunan shaped a ball away from Jason Sangha, who edged behind, and at the end of the first day, Randwick-Petersham needed 150 runs with seven wickets in hand.  It didn’t look all that demanding, especially when the score reached 3 for 72, but the introduction of Raval’s leg spin caused immediate chaos.  Ashley Burton, leaning forward, nicked another catch to keeper Gus Small; Riley Ayre was lbw, propping forward; and when Cam Hawkins, playing back, edged to Matt Day at slip, Raval’s spell had delivered three wickets for only two runs.  Blacktown won by the deceptively wide margin of 62 runs, and join Randwick-Petersham on 37 points, just three points away from sixth place.

Frankie Nicklin is on the way up

Without attracting a great deal of fanfare, Sydney University all-rounder Frankie Nicklin is enjoying the kind of season that suggests she has a very promising future in the game.  A 19 year old first-year university student, Nicklin was the leading wicket-taker in this season’s national Under-19 Championships, and her form in Premier Cricket has been consistently impressive.  Bowling tidy off-breaks with an economical action, Nicklin bowled immaculately against Gordon, taking 5-25 (she actually wrapped up the Gordon innings by taking five for five in her last three overs).  Against Campbelltown-Camden, she set up University’s win with a lively innings of 104, her first century of the season.  Her batting, like her bowling, is neat, correct and well-organised, and she has some fluent off-side strokes.  Nicklin, who has already played once for the NSW Breakers in the WNCL, has been identified as a likely prospect for some time, but her performances this season indicate that she’s ready to step up into representative cricket on a more regular basis.

Next week, the scorer’s opening the bowling

Weird game of the week was at Mike Pawley Oval, where Manly’s table-topping Fifth Grade side took on Parramatta.  Manly found itself struggling for numbers, and so pressed into action its Third Grade manager, Will Gustafson, and its Fourth Grade manager, Noah Vumbaca, neither of who had played for the club this season, or indeed, expected to play.  That didn’t seem very significant when Parramatta subsided to 9 for 132, but Harry Willoughby and Avyukt Iyer then made the game a little interesting by adding another 70 runs for the last wicket.  Parramatta captain Liam Gillies then grabbed five wickets to leave Manly struggling at 9 for 175, still needing 28 and with only the two late recruits to bat.  To begin with, they poked and prodded, picking up the occasional single, but Gustafson and Vumbaca inched closer to the target, and Vumbaca settled the issue by hitting two fours in the 80th over.  So across the two innings, the last wicket added 98 runs for the loss of one wicket, while 18 other wickets fell for 307 runs.  None of which makes a good deal of sense.